Eric wants to hire an ex-convict to be the new organist as the church vestry's the opposition. Acting church treasurer, Annie must determine whether there is enough money in the church's budget to hire a new organist. Meanwhile, Lucy becomes jealous after she makes Mary tutor her boyfriend Jimmy Moon. Simon does his best at trying to get Matt into letting him get a tetanus shot at the doctor's office. Lastly, Ruthie feels empowered by her new class phone list and decides to test the emergency phone numbers.

While Cardassian voles are being removed from Quark's, the owner laments his pitiful life. Being a Ferengi who is banned from doing business with other Ferengi is tough on Quark. Rom suggests that he pay a visit to mother while Leeta and he prepare for their wedding. All Rom has to do is make her sign the Ferengi Waiver of Property and Profit.

Caroline is sued by the mother of a victim of a failed rescue. C.J'.s desire for motherhood hits a snag when she realizes Cody's not ready for that type of commitment.