When Andrew is given the opportunity to ask out a model, he is forced to realize that even a gentleman can be shallow about some things. Meanwhile, Bert discovers that events from his past may be the reason for his commitment issues.

An incident from a client's college days becomes problematic for Mitch; Abby must decide if she can work for Joey Morolto Jr.

In a special Mystery Box Challenge the contestants quickly learn that they must warm the cockles of the judges' hearts with a tasty soup.

Venom resurfaces using Harry as his host yet again; this time Harry's neglecting father becomes his main target. While Norman Osborn does not want his potential secret weapon damaged, Spider-Man is confronted with the dilemma of either trying to help Harry on his own or putting his trust in his teammates, who have orders from Fury to finish Venom off.

S.H.I.E.L.D. Director Maria Hill contacts the Avengers to deal with the Hulk who is destroying the helicarrier.

Meanwhile, the impostor Captain America continues his infiltration of the Avengers team.